TEXT
Brazil plowed billions of dollars into building a railroad across arid backlands, only for the longdelayed project to fall prey to metal scavengers. Curvaceous new public buildings designed by the famed architect Oscar Niemeyer were abandoned \right after being constructed. There was even an illfated U.F.O. museum built with federal funds. Its skeletal remains now sit like a lost ship among the weeds.
As Brazil sprints to get ready for the World Cup ∈June, it has run up against a catalog of delays, some caused by deadly construction accidents at stadiums, and cost overruns. It is building bus and rail systems for spectators that will not be finished until long after the games are done. But the World Cup projects are just a part of a bigger national problem casting a pall over Brazil’s grand ambitions: an array of lavish projects conceived when economic growth was surging that now stand abandoned, stalled or wildly over budget.
Some economists say the troubled projects reveal a crippling bureaucracy, irresponsible allocation of resources and bastions of corruption.
Huge street protests have been aimed at costly new stadiums being built ∈ cities like Manaus and Brasília, whose paltry fan bases are almost sure to leave a sea of empty seats after the World Cup events are finished, adding to concerns that even more white elephants will emerge from the tournament.
“The fiascos are multiplying, revealing disarray that is regrettably systemic,” said Gil Castello Branco, director of Contas Abertas, a Brazilian watchdog group that scrutinizes public budgets. “We’re waking up to the reality that immense resources have been wasted on extravagant projects when our public schools are still a mess and raw sewage is still ∈ our streets.”
The growing list of troubled development projects includes a $3.4 billion network of concrete canals ∈ the drought-plagued hinterland of northeast Brazil — which was supposed to be finished ∈2010 — as well as dozens of new wind farms idled by a lack of transmission lines and unfinished luxury hotels blighting Rio de Janeiro’s skyline.
Economists surveyed by the nation’s central bank see Brazil’s economy growing just 1.63 percent this year, down from 7.5 percent ∈2010, making 2014 the fourth straight year of slow growth.
President Dilma Rousseff’s supporters contend that the public spending has worked, helping to keep unemployment at historical lows and preventing what would have been a much worse economic slowdown had the government not pumped its considerable resources into infrastructure development.
Still, a growing chorus of critics argues that the inability to finish big infrastructure projects reveals weaknesses ∈Brazil’s model of state capitalism. First, they say, Brazil gives extraordinary influence to a web of state-controlled companies, banks and pension funds to invest ∈ ill-advised projects. Then other bastions of the vast public bureaucracy cripple projects with audits and lawsuits.
“Some ventures never deserved public money ∈ the first place,” said Sérgio Lazzarini, an economist at Insper, a São Paulo business school, pointing to the millions ∈ state financing for the overhaul of the Glória hotel ∈Rio, owned until recently by a mining tycoon, Eike Batista. The project was \left unfinished, unable to open for the World Cup, when Mr. Batista’s business empire crumbled last year. “For infrastructure projects which deserve state support and get it,” Mr. Lazzarini continued, “there’s the daunting task of dealing with the risks that the state itself creates.”
The Transnordestina, a railroad begun ∈2006 here ∈ northeast Brazil, illustrates some of the pitfalls plaguing projects big and small. Scheduled to be finished ∈2010 at a cost of about 1.8billion,therailroad,designedtostretchmorethan1,000miles,isnowexpectedtocostatleast3.2 billion, with most financing from state banks. Officials say it should be completed around 2016. But with work sites abandoned because of audits and other setbacks months ago ∈ and around Paulistana, a town ∈Piauí, one of Brazil’s poorest states, even that timeline seems optimistic. Long stretches where freight trains were already supposed to be running stand deserted. Wiry vaqueiros, or cowboys, herd cattle ∈ the shadow of ghostly railroad bridges that tower 150 feet above parched valleys. “Thieves are pillaging metal from the work sites,” said Adailton Vieira da Silva, 42, an electrician who labored with thousands of others before work halted last year. “Now there are just these bridges \left \in the \middle of nowhere.”
Brazil’s transportation minister, César Borges, expressed exasperation with the delays ∈ finishing the railroad, which is needed to transport soybean harvests to port. He listed the bureaucracies that delay projects like the Transnordestina: the Federal Court of Accounts; the Office of the Comptroller General; an environmental protection agency; an institute protecting archaeological patrimony; agencies protecting the rights of indigenous peoples and descendants of escaped slaves; and the Public Ministry, a body of independent prosecutors. Still, Mr. Borges insisted, “Projects get delayed ∈ countries around the world, not just Brazil.”
Some economists contend that the way Brazil is investing may be hampering growth instead of supporting it. The authorities encouraged energy companies to build wind farms, but dozens cannot operate because they lack transmission lines to connect to the electricity grid. Meanwhile, manufacturers worry over potential electricity rationing as reservoirs at hydroelectric dams run dry amid a drought.
Then there is the extraterrestrial museum ∈Varginha, a city ∈ southeast Brazil where residents claimed to have seen an alien ∈1996. Officials secured federal money to build the museum, but now all that remains of the unfinished project is the rusting carcass of what looks like a flying saucer. “That museum,” said Roberto Macedo, an economist at the University of São Paulo, “is an insult to both extraterrestrials and the terrestrial beings like ourselves who foot the bill for yet another project failing to deliver.”
Adapted from www.nytimes.com/April 12, 2014.
The two sentences “‘Some ventures never deserved public money ∈ the first place,’ said Sérgio Lazzarini, an economist at Insper, a São Paulo business school” and “‘That museum,’ said Roberto Macedo, an economist at the University of São Paulo, ‘is an insult to both extraterrestrials and the terrestrial beings like ourselves who foot the bill for yet another project failing to deliver’” contain, respectively, examples of
