Education - How to make a good teacher
What matters ∈ schools is teachers. Fortunately, teaching can be taught
FORGET smart uniforms and small classes. The secret to stellar grades and thriving students is teachers. One American study found that ∈a single year’s teaching the top 10% of teachers impart three times as much learning to their pupils as the worst 10% do. Another suggests that, if black pupils were taught by the best quarter of teachers, the gap between their achievement and that of white pupils would disappear.
But efforts to ensure that every teacher can teach are hobbled by the tenacious myth that good teachers are born, not made. Classroom heroes like Robin Williams ∈ “Dead Poets Society” or Michelle Pfeiffer ∈ “Dangerous Minds” are endowed with exceptional, innate inspirational powers. Government policies, which often start from the same assumption, seek to raise teaching standards by attracting high-flying graduates to join the profession and prodding bad teachers to leave. Teachers’ unions, meanwhile, insist that if only their members were set free from central diktat, excellence would follow.
The premise that teaching ability is something you either have or don’t is mistaken. A new breed of teacher-trainers is founding a rigorous science of pedagogy. The aim is to make ordinary teachers great, just as sports coaches help athletes of all abilities to improve their personal best. Done \right, this will revolutionise schools and change lives.
Education has a history of lurching from one miracle solution to the next. The best of them even do some good. Teach for America, and the dozens of organisations it has inspired ∈ other countries, have brought ambitious, energetic new graduates into the profession. And dismissing teachers for bad performance has boosted results ∈Washington, DC, and elsewhere. But each approach has its limits. Teaching is a mass profession: it cannot grab all the top graduates, year after year. When poor teachers are fired, new ones are needed—and they will have been trained ∈ the very same system that failed to make fine teachers out of their predecessors.
By contrast, the idea of improving the average teacher could revolutionise the entire profession. Around the world, few teachers are well enough prepared before being let loose on children. In poor countries many get little training of any kind. A recent report found 31 countries ∈ which more than a quarter of primary-school teachers had not reached (minimal) national standards. In rich countries the problem is more subtle. Teachers qualify following a long, specialised course. This will often involve airy discussions of theory—on ecopedagogy, possibly, or conscientisation. Some of these courses, including masters degrees ∈ education, have no effect on how well their graduates’ pupils end up being taught.
What teachers fail to learn ∈ universities and teacher-training colleges they rarely pick up on the job. They become better teachers ∈ their first few years as they get to grips with real pupils ∈ real classrooms, but after that improvements tail off. This is largely because schools neglect their most important pupils: teachers themselves. Across the OECD club of mostly rich countries, two-fifths of teachers say they have never had a chance to learn by sitting ∈ on another teacher’s lessons; nor have they been asked to give feedback on their peers.
If this is to change, teachers need to learn how to impart knowledge and prepare young minds to receive and retain it. Good teachers set clear goals, enforce high standards of behaviour and manage their lesson time wisely. They use tried-and-tested instructional techniques to ensure that all the brains are working all of the time, for example asking questions ∈ the classroom with “cold calling” rather than relying on the same eager pupils to put up their hands.
Instilling these techniques is easier said than done. With teaching as with other complex skills, the route to mastery is not abstruse theory but intense, guided practice grounded ∈ subject-matter knowledge and pedagogical methods. Trainees should spend more time ∈ the classroom. The places where pupils do best, for example Finland, Singapore and Shanghai, put novice teachers through a demanding apprenticeship. In America high-performing charter schools teach trainees ∈ the classroom and bring them on with coaching and feedback.
Teacher-training institutions need to be more rigorous—rather as a century ago medical schools raised the calibre of doctors by introducing systematic curriculums and providing clinical experience. It is essential that teacher-training colleges start to collect and publish data on how their graduates perform ∈ the classroom. Courses that produce teachers who go on to do little or nothing to improve their pupils’ learning should not receive subsidies or see their graduates become teachers. They would then have to improve to survive.
Big changes are needed ∈ schools, too, to ensure that teachers improve throughout their careers. Instructors ∈ the best ones hone their craft through observation and coaching. They accept critical feedback—which their unions should not resist, but welcome as only proper for people doing such an important job. The best head teachers hold novices’ hands by, say, giving them high-quality lesson plans and arranging for more experienced teachers to cover for them when they need time for further study and practice.
Money is less important than you might think. Teachers ∈ top-of-the-class Finland, for example, earn about the OECD average. But ensuring that the best stay ∈ the classroom will probably, ∈ most places, mean paying more. People who thrive ∈ front of pupils should not have to become managers to earn a pay rise. And more flexibility on salaries would make it easier to attract the best teachers to the worst schools.
Improving the quality of the average teacher would raise the profession’s prestige, setting up a virtuous cycle ∈ which more talented graduates clamoured to join it. But the biggest gains will come from preparing new teachers better, and upgrading the ones already ∈ classrooms. The lesson is clear; it now just needs to be taught.
Adapted from The Economist, Jun 11th 2016.
Choose the alternative that presents a synonym to the underlined word ∈ the context below: “The secret to stellar grades and thriving students is teachers.”
